HerbieG's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[The HeartBit]

Well, I have to admit that those are probably one of the most annoying controls I have ever met. Inconsistent when it comes to the length and the height of the jump, slippy like hell with terrible mid-air control.

Besides, I finished one of the levels without collecting any of the DNA but my total amount still went up. Oh, while The Vaccine character has a description that it can save Miguel the medal for me unlocked instantly after I reached 150, is this intentional?

[Slide Together]

You've got a disconnection problem and reloading the game does not re-send the medals.

PS:

The problem is that after some time the game disconnects from NG and the only way to get the missing medal is to replay the level that unlocks it.

Rob1221 responds:

I don't know why some players are unable to unlock medals, but I do see your name in the medal list now.

[My First Game]

I am constantly receiving this error message when loading the game:
Could not compile vertex shader:

ERROR: 1:1: '' : syntax error

2 more things:
1. Hit detection in hexscape is a bit weird, it would be better if it was mouse-controlled;
2. 3D runner is laggy like hell.

Also your game has a disconnection problem, quite fast it disconnects from NG and fails to send medals.

HealliesGames responds:

Thank you for the feedback HerbieG!
That error appears to my friend too, I see if I can replicate and investigate the cause.

For Hexscape, I'm going to reduce the hitbox, but the maximum difficulty is calculated to the millimeter to be played with the arrows.

3D Cube Runner unfortunately lags on HTML5, on Windows goes well. I'll try to optimize it even more.

For the medals I should have understood what's wrong: I will solve this too.

[Super Bounce Ball]

Keep in mind everything that @NeonSpider wrote you about performance of your games, because having to refresh the game every few tries to deal with the lag and frame losses/lack of control is just annoying. I guess you would prefer to get more views because the game is good rather than because of those issues. Remember to put an option to turn off all particle effects in your games, because obviously visuals are far less important than performance. Especially levels with those turrets and animations of their triangular "bullets" are a pain because of that.

Also like @Verlock wrote: those flashing effects are really not necessary.

And @MeGa-wise is right about the disconnection problem, although if you re-enter any of the levels you are missing medals from they are being re-sent.

MrNannings responds:

Yes, It may be too late for you. But I added the option to turn off most of the particle fx.

[CaverMan 2020]

Same problem like @Rsharp723894 reported here. Tried on Firefox and Chrome. The game freezes either when I start to throw rocks or after several hits on the boss. In fact, the game froze for me even on other levels, at least that was manageable.

[Stones of Anarchy: Flight of the Stone]

This game requires so rapid clicking to even pass few of the "pipes" that it becomes ridiculous. And honestly I doubt that it will land on the front page...

StonesOfAnarchy responds:

Come on Herbie where's your enthusiasm! It's not an impossible game!

[Munguía Nokia Games]

Well, I've got to say that I'm not impressed by this one. Could use some polishing, like hit detection for example. Steering in Impact space is just awful. Oh, for Guac-a-mole you could simply use the num-pad keys.

Oh, by the way: in lots of situations the game freezes.

Munguia responds:

Thanks for comment and Play Mr HerbieG, the laptops are out of numpad keys, thats the reason why STENCYL dont allow PC KEYBOARD NUMBER KEYPAD, not my choice, but as a fast skill blind typer, i recomment to take a look on the bump you can feel and touch on letter J, thats what we call a REFERENCE GUIDE MARK to put your middle finger, it works for Guacamole game, but is typical if you know how to type. on letter F theres another bump, the same for your Left Hand

[Roadside Boardin']

Interesting, but too many blind jumps. The game's rng is also generating impossible scenarios, many times I even did not begin at all playing because I landed on one of the animals... that should not be happening. Also: 10 000 points with these controls and all things I mentioned? Really?

GoodL responds:

That's fair - although if you're using all 3 layers of platforms you shouldn't run into impossible scenarios. If you're getting animals right at the start though that is a problem and I'll have to take a look at that. Thanks!

[AreYouMadness?]

Terrible lack of optimization. Lags like hell. Quality changing changes nothing. Clicks register with a horrible delay.

[Scrap Memories - Chapter One]

Nice new game from you, but with several flaws. I am playing it on an Intel-type CPU and on Firefox and the game certainly has one major issue: during dialogue sequences or opening the bins the game can freeze even for several minutes. For example currently I am waiting for nearly 10 minutes for the game to close the dialogue box after I picked up an item so I can continue playing. And without any export/import save feature I would have to start the game on other browser from the very beginning. It's bad that you did not ensure that the game can be played without problems on both major browsers. Also - as you stated that you want to go for a Kickstarter - do your best so the game could be played on all types of CPUs/GPUs, because if it will be "excluding" the AMD users because of performance problems it can seriously harm your monetization plans.

BigBossErndog responds:

Thanks for letting me know! At least it seems I've narrowed it down to it being Firefox, rather than AMD. It just so happened the first couple of people to report it also had AMD processors. Since then people with Intel CPUs have reported the problem, so the issue must be isolated to Firefox.

Seems to be a strange problem with Phaser 3 as this has not been reported with previous games which all used Phaser 2. I can't replicate this behavior myself, it works fine on my laptop (which is the only device I have to test this on) so this is very difficult to fix.
Thankfully the testers who have encountered this problem have reported that the issue is resolved if they use another browser, such as Chrome.

All I can say to players is to avoid Firefox.

The offline version will hopefully be fine then, because it will be running on NW.js which is Chromium based. None of my testers have had problems running it offline on NW.js.

I will be reporting this issue to both Phaser and Mozilla, and hopefully we can resolve this :)